Handcrafted from Scratch
Every cookie, bar, fudge slice, and candy is made by hand in our shoppe — using the same trusted recipes that built Nan's reputation over three and a half decades.
Our Story
A 35-year tradition, in loving new hands.
Welcome to Nan's Nummies — our store of 35 years is now under the ownership of Crystal McLemore, a passionate baker and longtime member of the Nan's family.
Meet Crystal
Crystal took the reins of this beloved candy shop in April 2023 — building on Nan's legacy while infusing her own touch of creativity and innovation.
At Nan's Nummies, we believe that indulging in delicious treats is an experience that should be cherished. With a dedication to the art of confectionery, Crystal is determined to continue delighting our valued customers with the same exceptional quality and flavors that have made Nan's a staple in the Historic Valley Junction neighborhood.
Nan's Nummies has a long-standing tradition of handcrafting delectable delights, and Crystal fully embraces this approach. Using the original 35-year-old recipe for success, we take pride in creating our treats from scratch — because there's simply no better way. From our almond cream cookies and classic homemade fudge to our frosted cookies, Dutch letters, and an array of candies, we offer a wide variety of sweets to satisfy every craving.
"Crystal's dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every treat that leaves our shop." — The Nan's Nummies Family
While honoring Nan's traditional menu items that have garnered a loyal following, Crystal also plans to introduce her own creative additions. Indulge in our mouthwatering custom cakes, custom cupcakes, and custom cookies for any occasion. Crafted with meticulous attention to detail, our custom cakes are tailored to your unique vision, making them the centerpiece of your celebrations.
In addition to our existing chocolates, cookies, bulk candies, Dutch letters, saltwater taffy, and fudge, Nan's Nummies now proudly offers a range of specialty treats. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, wedding, or any other special event, our custom cakes and cupcakes will add a touch of sweetness and elegance to your festivities.
What We Stand For
Made from scratch, made with love.
Three things have stayed the same for 35 years — and they're not changing anytime soon.
A 35-Year Legacy
Nan's classics — almond cream cookies, homemade fudge, Dutch letters, and saltwater taffy — live on, made the original way and crafted with the same care.
Custom for Every Occasion
Custom cakes, cupcakes, and decorated cookies for birthdays, weddings, and milestones — designed to your vision and finished with Crystal's artistic flair.
At Nan's Nummies, we value our customers and strive to provide an exceptional experience with every visit. Crystal's dedication to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in every treat that leaves our shop. We invite you to savor the irresistible flavors of Nan's homemade creations, made with love and care.
Under Crystal's ownership, Nan's Nummies continues to be a place where culinary artistry and sweet delights converge. Join us in celebrating the legacy of Nan's while embracing the exciting new chapter that Crystal brings to this cherished candy shop.
Come Say Hi
Visit us today and taste the legacy.
Whether you're in the mood for our classic treats or seeking custom cakes, cupcakes, or cookies for a special occasion, we'd love to see you in the shoppe.